Fitch: Florida Homeowners’ Insurers Performance Deterioration Continues

Africa Asia Australia Business Canada Europe Florida News Health Latin America Middle East Science Tech UK Uncategorized USA World

Florida homeowners’ insurance specialists are reporting continued performance deterioration and a decline in capitalization levels, despite the most severe losses from the record 2020 hurricane season occurring outside of the Florida market, Fitch Ratings said in a recent report.

According to the rating agency, underwriting losses rose sharply for a group of 28 property/casualty (P/C) insurers focused on Florida homeowners’ insurance business, accounting for 60% of direct state market share for the $10 billion of direct premiums written in the state. The specialists had an aggregate combined ratio of 131% through 9M20 versus 111% at year-end 2019.

Florida homeowners’ insurance premium rates are rising in response to these poorer underlying loss trends and past catastrophe losses. Requested base rate increases in excess of 10% were common across Florida specialist carriers’ 2020 annual rate filings.

Fitch said carriers have cited rapid growth in litigation from non-catastrophe water damage claims as a driver of higher losses, as the pace of property damage claims that result in a lawsuit in Florida remains elevated relative to the broader U.S. market. Litigated claims tend to settle at values well in excess of those without a lawsuit, from both higher indemnity payments and defense costs.

Recovery in underwriting results from rate increases have been offset by higher reinsurance costs, with Florida-focused mid-year 2020 renewals showing a second year of sizable reinsurance rate increases, in some cases as much as 30%-35%.

Florida homeowners’ insurance specialists have business profiles characterized by limited scale and concentration in a volatile product segment, with further poor segment performance potentially leading to market exits and consolidation, Fitch said. Combined with less favorable risk-adjusted capital levels, high dependence on reinsurance and the recent poor profitability trends, the large majority of these companies would be rated below ‘BBB’ by Fitch.

Source: Fitch Ratings

Was this article valuable?

Here are more articles you may enjoy.

Leave a Reply